Is Expensive Toothpaste Worth It?

Dr. Lawnin
Dr. Lawnin

Is Expensive Toothpaste Worth It?

Dr. Lawnin
Dr. Lawnin

Sometimes. Expensive toothpaste is worth it when the price pays for active ingredients, like a high percentage of nano-hydroxyapatite together with fluoride. It's not worth it when you're paying for packaging, flavor or a brand story. Dr. Lawnin's test is simple: does it have fluoride or nano-hydroxyapatite, and does it skip the ingredients you don't need?

Premium pastes that earn it

  • Dr. Jen's SuperPaste (9/10): fluoride plus 10% nano-hydroxyapatite, xylitol and no SLS. It's expensive, and in Dr. Lawnin's words, "that's okay." He says if he designed a toothpaste, it would be close to this one.
  • Risewell Pro Mineral (8.5/10): micro and nano-hydroxyapatite plus ingredients that support healthy bacteria.
  • Mouthology (good): 10% nano-hydroxyapatite, xylitol, baking soda and no SLS, for about $12.

Premium pastes that don't

  • Euthymol Whitening (−3 million): no fluoride, no nano-hydroxyapatite, plus SLS. Very expensive. "You're buying an idea."
  • Marvis (−3 to 1): no fluoride in the US, plus SLS. Beautiful tubes.
  • Aesop (2/10): a great soap brand, but no fluoride or nano-hydroxyapatite.

Cheap pastes that beat expensive ones

  • Arm & Hammer Essentials: fluoride, baking soda, no SLS and very low abrasion, on every pharmacy shelf.
  • Sensodyne: potassium nitrate for sensitivity and low abrasion.
  • Boka: nano-hydroxyapatite at an accessible price.

The rule that matters most

Dr. Lawnin's number one toothpaste is the one you'll actually use every day. A $26 paste that sits in a drawer does less than a $5 tube you use twice a day.

Frequently asked questions

Does more expensive toothpaste work better?

Only if the extra cost buys real active ingredients, like high-percentage nano-hydroxyapatite.

What should I look for on the label?

Fluoride or nano-hydroxyapatite, low abrasion and no SLS.

Is Marvis toothpaste worth it?

Not for protecting your teeth. The US versions don't contain fluoride.

Related reading

Read the label, not the tube

Next time you're in the aisle, flip the box and look for fluoride or nano-hydroxyapatite first. Isn't that a better guide than the packaging?

Subscribe to newsletter

Let’s Create A Plan That Fits You.

Whether you're looking to enhance your smile or simply maintain lifelong oral health, we’re here to guide you with expert care and honest conversations.

Dr. Reynolds Lawnin pointing to a dental X-ray on a monitor while a patient looks on