Waking up with sore teeth or struggling through the day with jaw pain can be exhausting. Many patients know about night guards, but far fewer have heard of day splints — and the difference between the two can be confusing.

Both appliances protect your teeth and jaw, but they serve very different purposes. Night guards are built for long-term wear, offering durable protection against clenching and grinding while you sleep. Day splints, on the other hand, are thinner, temporary devices often used to calm inflammation and give the jaw muscles a chance to relax. Some can even be made chairside for immediate relief.

In this article, we’ll break down when to use a day splint versus a night guard, what each feels like to wear, how long they last, and what you can expect in terms of cost and insurance coverage. With insights straight from the chairside experience, you’ll get a clear picture of which option may be best for your needs.

Here’s how to know which option may be right for you.

Day Splint vs. Night Guard: What’s the Difference?

When jaw pain strikes or you wake up with sore teeth, your dentist may recommend either a day splint or a night guard. While both look like clear appliances, their purpose is not the same.

A day splint is a short-term solution. It’s thin and designed to give your jaw muscles a break during the day, especially if you’re dealing with inflammation, soreness, or tension. As Kourtney explained, “A day splint is very temporary — it helps calm inflammation and relax the jaw before moving into a night guard.”

A night guard, on the other hand, is a long-term protective device. It’s thicker, more durable, and specifically built to handle the pressure of nighttime grinding or clenching. By absorbing that force, it helps prevent cracked teeth, enamel wear, and long-term damage to your bite.

Think of it this way: a day splint is like a temporary ice pack, while a night guard is protective gear to prevent future injuries. Both have their place, but they’re used at different stages of treatment.

Transition: Now that we’ve defined their purpose, let’s look more closely at how their designs differ and what that means for durability.

Design and Durability

One of the most noticeable differences between these two appliances is their construction. A night guard is intentionally made to be thicker and sturdier because it needs to stand up to nightly grinding forces. With proper care, a night guard can last several years.

Day splints, by contrast, are intentionally thin and discreet. They’re easier to wear in public or at work, but this also makes them less durable. As Kourtney pointed out, “A day splint has to be thinner because it affects the way people speak. Some get used to it, but most notice a little lisp.”

For patients:

• Night guard = longevity. A durable, long-term investment.
• Day splint = short-term relief. Best for flare-ups, not extended use.

Imagine the difference between a heavy-duty hiking boot and a lightweight slipper. Both serve a purpose, but one is built to withstand daily wear and tear, while the other is only meant for short-term comfort.

Transition: Of course, design and durability only matter if patients can actually wear the appliance comfortably. So what do real-world experiences look like with each option?

Comfort and Common Complaints

Comfort is where patients often draw the line. If something feels bulky, awkward, or uncomfortable, it’s likely to end up unused in a nightstand drawer.

With night guards, the most common complaint is difficulty sleeping when first starting out. However, patients who stick with it usually report the opposite over time. As Kourtney shared, “Most people, once they get in the routine, will say they can’t sleep without it.” That’s because the guard not only protects their teeth but also relieves tension they may not even realize was causing discomfort.

Day splints, meanwhile, can interfere with speech. For professionals who spend much of their day talking, this can be frustrating. While some adjust quickly, others prefer to use them sparingly, relying on them only during particularly painful periods.

The key takeaway: both appliances require an adjustment period. The first few days may feel awkward, but consistency pays off in comfort and results.

Transition: Beyond comfort, many patients naturally ask: will insurance help cover the cost of these appliances? Let’s explore the financial side.

Cost, Insurance, and Accessibility

Financial questions often come up when patients are considering dental appliances. The good news is that night guards are sometimes partially covered by insurance. Coverage varies by plan, but many policies recognize the preventive value of protecting teeth from grinding damage.

Day splints, however, are rarely covered. Because they’re considered temporary solutions, insurance companies usually don’t reimburse for them. The silver lining is that day splints are often made quickly and in-office, keeping costs lower. Some, like “quick splints,” are created chairside on the same day — offering patients immediate relief without the expense of a lab-made device.

In short: the night guard is a long-term investment, while the day splint is a quick, budget-friendly fix.

Transition: So how exactly are these appliances made, and what should you expect during the fitting process?

The Fitting Process: What to Expect

Getting fitted for these appliances is another area where the experiences differ.

• Day Splint: In many cases, day splints can be made on the spot. A quick splint, for example, is shaped right in the chair and delivered immediately. There are also pre-made versions stored in the office (sometimes even kept in the freezer) that can be adapted quickly to a patient’s needs.
• Night Guard: Night guards require more precision. Patients are typically scanned digitally (similar to the process for retainers), and the guard is fabricated in a lab. This ensures a comfortable, custom fit designed to last.

The difference comes down to speed vs. precision. If you walk into the office with jaw pain, you may leave that same day with a day splint for relief. But if your concern is long-term grinding damage, a carefully fitted night guard is the better investment.

Transition: Now that we’ve explored purpose, design, comfort, cost, and fitting, let’s bring it all together with a clear summary of when to use each option.

Conclusion

Choosing between a day splint and a night guard doesn’t have to be overwhelming. As we’ve explored, the two serve very different purposes. A day splint offers short-term relief for sore, inflamed jaws, giving your muscles a chance to recover. A night guard, meanwhile, provides long-term protection against grinding and clenching, helping to preserve your teeth and support jaw health for years to come.

Splints are thinner and designed for short-term comfort, while guards are built for durability. Some patients find the adjustment period challenging — whether it’s getting used to a lisp with a splint or falling asleep with a guard — but consistency often transforms these appliances into essentials. Cost and coverage may also influence your choice, with night guards sometimes supported by insurance, while splints are often provided in-office as affordable, temporary solutions.

At Tanglewood Dental Associates, we focus on helping patients find lasting comfort and protection tailored to their lifestyle. Whether you need immediate relief or a long-term safeguard, our team can guide you toward the right option with clarity and care.

If you’re experiencing jaw pain or suspect you may be grinding your teeth, your next step is simple: schedule a consultation. Book a visit today and take the first step toward a healthier, more comfortable smile.

‍