Introduction

Whitening toothpastes promise a brighter smile, but not all of them live up to that claim. Some formulas gently lift surface stains, while others can actually wear down your enamel over time. So which ones truly work, and which should you leave on the shelf?

We spoke with Dr. Lawnin who rated popular whitening toothpastes on a scale of one to ten.

In this breakdown, we’ll explore what separates a safe, effective whitening toothpaste from one that’s too abrasive. You’ll learn why baking soda gets high marks for being both gentle and effective, why charcoal toothpastes deserve a firm “no,” and how fluoride or nanohydroxyapatite help strengthen your teeth while keeping them bright.

Whether you’re chasing a Hollywood smile or simply want a healthier mouth, Dr. Lawnin’s expert insights will help you choose wisely — because the right toothpaste shouldn’t just whiten your teeth; it should protect them too.

The Science Behind Whitening Toothpaste

Whitening toothpaste sounds simple — brush, rinse, smile brighter — but the science tells a more nuanced story. Most whitening formulas don’t bleach your teeth like professional treatments do. Instead, they target extrinsic stains — discoloration from coffee, tea, or wine that builds up on the enamel surface.

Dr. Lawnin explains that the key lies in the ingredients. “Whitening toothpastes remove surface stains,” he says, “but they don’t whiten the enamel itself.” That distinction matters. The polishing agents used for stain removal — such as baking soda or mild abrasives — vary in safety and effectiveness.

Just as important is strengthening your teeth while you whiten. Fluoride has long been the standard for reinforcing enamel and preventing cavities. For those seeking fluoride-free options, nanohydroxyapatite is a promising alternative. It mimics your teeth’s natural minerals, helping rebuild and protect enamel at a microscopic level.

When choosing a whitening toothpaste, look for one that removes stains and supports tooth structure. The brightest smiles are built on strong foundations.

Dr. Lawnin’s Ratings: The Good, the Bad, and the Abrasive

⭐ Arm & Hammer Advanced White – 10/10

Topping Dr. Lawnin’s list is Arm & Hammer Advanced White Baking Soda Toothpaste. “Baking soda is incredibly kind to teeth,” he says. “It removes surface stains without being harsh.” Its soft texture gently polishes teeth while protecting enamel, creating whiter, healthier results — no damage required.

⚠️ Marvis Whitening Toothpaste – 1/10

Marvis may look elegant on your bathroom counter, but it’s all style and little substance. “It’s old-school and cool,” says Dr. Lawnin, “but it doesn’t do a whole lot for your teeth.” The problem? No fluoride or enamel-strengthening ingredients. It’s an aesthetic choice, not a functional one.

⚠️ Crest 3D White – 2/10

Crest 3D White is popular but too abrasive. “It’s too hard on teeth,” warns Dr. Lawnin. Prolonged use can wear down the tooth structure. While it does contain fluoride, the potential for physical wear lowers its score significantly.

❌ Colgate Optic White with Charcoal – (-10)/10

“Do not buy toothpaste with charcoal in it,” Dr. Lawnin emphasizes. Despite its trendy image, charcoal is highly abrasive and can permanently damage enamel. Once enamel is gone, it doesn’t come back — and no whitening product can replace it.

✅ Sensodyne Extra Whitening – 7/10

For those with sensitive teeth, Sensodyne Extra Whitening earns high marks. “It has a little bit of grip,” says Dr. Lawnin. “It works well without causing irritation.” With fluoride and anti-sensitivity compounds, it provides gentle whitening and long-term protection.

👍 Tom’s Whitening + Deep Clean – 8/10

Tom’s stands out among natural brands, especially versions with fluoride or nanohydroxyapatite. “It’s a good toothpaste,” Dr. Lawnin notes. “As long as it has fluoride or nanohydroxyapatite, it does the job well.” Its natural ingredients and mild abrasives make it both effective and safe.

⚖️ Colgate Total Whitening – 5/10

Middle of the pack, Colgate Total Whitening offers reliable results with a less abrasive formula than Optic White. The downside? A heavier chemical profile. Still, it’s a solid everyday option for those wanting a balance between conventional performance and enamel care.

“The right whitening toothpaste doesn’t just polish your teeth — it protects them.”

Choosing the Right Toothpaste for You

With countless whitening options lining store shelves, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed. Dr. Lawnin’s insights show that the best toothpaste isn’t the flashiest — it’s the one that protects your enamel while gently removing stains.

Here’s what to look for when shopping:

• Fluoride or Nanohydroxyapatite: Strengthens enamel and prevents decay.
• Gentle Abrasives: Baking soda is ideal for safe stain removal.
• No Charcoal: Despite the marketing, it’s too harsh for daily use.
• Consistency: Whitening results come from regular use, not aggressive formulas.

Think of toothpaste as skincare for your teeth — it should nourish, not strip away. The goal isn’t to “scrub” your enamel white but to maintain a healthy, naturally radiant smile through consistent care.

Key Takeaways from Dr. Lawnin

If there’s one message Dr. Lawnin emphasizes, it’s this: a whiter smile should never come at the expense of your enamel.

• Avoid harsh abrasives like charcoal that can erode enamel.
• Choose gentle cleansers such as baking soda for safe stain removal.
• Support enamel health with fluoride or nanohydroxyapatite.
• Don’t fall for flashy packaging — simplicity wins.

“Whitening toothpaste should make your teeth shine — not shrink,” says Dr. Lawnin. With the right formula, you can safely brighten your smile and strengthen it at the same time.

Conclusion

At the end of the day, a brighter smile isn’t about chasing the latest whitening trend — it’s about making smart, science-backed choices that protect your teeth for the long haul.

Dr. Lawnin’s evaluations reveal that the most effective whitening toothpastes are often the simplest ones. Baking soda-based options like Arm & Hammer Advanced White deliver gentle stain removal while preserving enamel, and fluoride or nanohydroxyapatite help rebuild your teeth from within. In contrast, harsh abrasives — particularly charcoal — can undo years of good dental care.

If you take one thing away from this article, let it be this: whitening should never come at the expense of your tooth health. The best toothpaste doesn’t just polish your smile — it protects it.

Next time you’re in the toothpaste aisle, check the ingredient list instead of the label claims. Look for enamel-supporting ingredients, skip the charcoal, and prioritize long-term oral health.

At Tanglewood Dental Associates, we believe oral care should always be effective, safe, and transparent. We’re here to help you make confident, science-backed choices — because your healthiest, brightest smile starts with smart habits and the right toothpaste.

‍